The Mormon Militia depicted in the new Netflix show American Primeval is insane for all the wrong reasons. . This gritty “historical fiction” of the old American West features members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, commonly known as Mormons, as villains. . Yet even one of the show’s historical consultants admitted, it's “definitely not an accurate history of anything,” so here's what it gets wrong about Latter-day Saint history. . First the show has a Mormon militia known as the Nauvoo Legion riding in with hoods to destroy an innocent pioneer company, and then it eliminates an entire regiment of US Federal Troops, and then an entire Shoshone village, just to cover their tracks. . In reality, the Nauvoo legion never, once, saw, combat. . Latter-day Saints also never attacked a wagon train of pioneers at Fort Bridger. . Nor did they harm a single soldier of the US Federal Army. Even during the “Utah War.” . And they never destroyed a Shoshone village to cover their tracks of the first crime. . All of these plot elements paint Latter-day Saints as a radical and zealously hostile religious group, yet all of these plot points are 100% fiction. . Some of the show’s characters are based on real people, such as Brigham Young, Bill Hickman, and Jim Bridger. . Yet again, this is more fiction than fact, such as in the depiction of Brigham Young as a ruthless and unaliving empire builder, which is simply not supported by the documents we have of his life. . Now to be clear, there are examples in Latter-day Saint history where they were the aggressors, such as in the Mountain Meadows Mass***e, or the Black Hawk War. These are complex and horrifying events that I think deserve careful study and discussion. . But the way this show exaggerates, expands, and conflates multiple, isolated events into a single plot—just to ramp up the violins—can perpetuate harmful stereotypes about the religion. . To learn the truth about Mountain Meadows, I recommend watching this video on the Scripture Central YouTube channel. .
#lds #prolds #churchofjesuschristoflatterdaysaints #churchhistory #brighamyoung #mountainmeadows